Is the Cookie Monster Eating Your Commissions?
Posted on February 4th, 2008 by DotComMogul under Affiliate Marketing, affiliate networks, commissions, cookie tracking, cookies, cpa networksWelcome. If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Don't forget to leave a comment. I * DO * FOLLOW so you get a link back.
Visit Firestorm Forums for Free Traffic and Promotion Resources
I’ve put together an Affiliate/CPA Directory for you to help you choose ad networks and products to promote. Another consideration when choosing your networks is the problem of affiliate cookies being intercepted by popular spyware detection programs. The problem of cookie deletion has long been a problem of the online ad industry. A report from independent spyware researcher Ben Edelman highlights the degree to which spyware detection software gobbles up your commissions by intercepting affiliate cookies.
Edelman studied 11 spyware detection programs to determine which ones devoured cookies from a range of 50 ad systems, including ad networks, affiliate networks and Yahoo’s and Google’s pay-per-click ad systems. These spyware detection programs included McAfee Internet Security Suite, Symantec’s Norton Internet Security and Microsoft Windows Defender, LavaSoft’s Ad-Aware, PC Tools’s Spybot Search and Destroy, Webroot’s Spy Sweeper, and ZoneAlarm Internet Security Suite.
In most cases, the wider the reach of the ad network, affiliate network or ad management system, the more readily it was tracked. For instance, the affiliate networks whose cookies were caught in spyware detection webs most often were the bigger ones: Linkshare and ValueClick’s BeFree were both snagged by seven of 11 programs. ValueClick’s Commission Junction and Tradedoubler, a European pay-per-performance service, were both nabbed by six. In comparison, affiliate networks like AffiliateFuel, DoubleClick’s Performics and AzoogleAds were found by only one or two spyware detection applications.
The same was true of ad networks Advertising.com, Casale Media and ValueClick’s FastClick, each of which had its cookies discovered by eight of the 11 spyware-tracking systems tested. Cookies from aQuantive’s Atlas ad management platform were found by eight programs, while DoubleClick’s and Zedo’s ad platform cookies were detected by seven programs. Cookies served by SEM management platform MatchCraft and behavioral targeting system Revenue Science were each tracked by only one spyware detector.
Spyware-sweeping software programs including PC Tools’s Spybot Search and Destroy, Trend Micro’s Anti-Spyware, LavaSoft’s Ad-Aware and Webroot’s Spy Sweeper each found more than 45 percent of cookies distributed by the ad systems analyzed. Yet, more widely-recognized programs such as Symantec’s Norton Internet Security, McAfee Internet Security Suite and Microsoft Windows Defender detected absolutely zero of the 50 ad systems tested for the study.
According to Shoemoney, ALL the blame falls on the affiliate networks.
Read the full report here. You will be better able to choose your Affiliate/CPA Networks armed with this information.
Popularity: 7% [?]

















February 4th, 2008 at 10:07 pm
[...] Welcome. If you’re new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!I made a list of CPA Affiliate Networks in an earlier post. This is a list of US and International Affiliate Networks that you get commission for selling products, rather than generating leads. I’m a member of Commission Junction (CJ), Linkshare (LS), Affiliate Future US, ClickBank, PayDotCom.com, ShareASale (SAS) and MarketHealth, with MarketHealth being my best performing now, but PayDotCom.com the best in the past. Hope you’ll find this list useful when searching for products to promote. If you run an affiliate program that is not listed, leave a comment and I will add it. More information needed to choose the best networks can be found in my newest Dot Com Mogul article: Is the Cookie Monster Eating Your Commissions? [...]
February 22nd, 2008 at 12:45 am
[...] US and International Affiliate Networks Posted on February 22nd, 2008 by DotComMogul under affiliate networks submit_url = “http://dotcommogul.net/affiliate-networks/us-and-international-affiliate-networks/”; Welcome. If you’re new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!I made a list of CPA Affiliate Networks in an earlier post. This is a list of US and International Affiliate Networks that you get commission for selling products, rather than generating leads. I’m a member of Commission Junction (CJ), Linkshare (LS), Affiliate Future US, ClickBank, PayDotCom.com, ShareASale (SAS) and MarketHealth, with MarketHealth being my best performing now, but PayDotCom.com the best in the past. Hope you’ll find this list useful when searching for products to promote. If you run an affiliate program that is not listed, leave a comment and I will add it. More information needed to choose the best networks can be found in my newest Dot Com Mogul article: Is the Cookie Monster Eating Your Commissions? [...]
March 22nd, 2008 at 3:20 pm
Dot Com Whiz,
Great post…but now the Cookie Monster is the Carrot Monster or something.
Sesame Street went vegetable.
Joseph Ratliff
Joseph Ratliff’s last blog post..10 Reasons Affiliate Marketing Kicks A$$
April 27th, 2008 at 12:45 am
Great post. It seems soon ads will be by webpage not these affiliate links with cookies anymore.
Mcneris: For Bloggerss last blog post..1